Once upon a time, people worried that television was becoming too sensational.
This was adorable.
Primetime takes us back to 2006, when To Catch a Predator was one of the strangest things ever broadcast by a major American network: real men, real crimes, hidden cameras, actors pretending to be children, police waiting outside and Chris Hansen walking into the room with the timing of Dracula entering a drawing room.
Robert Pattinson plays Hansen.
That sentence alone should tell you that Lance Oppenheim is not making a conventional biopic.
He isn’t.
Oppenheim, making his narrative-feature debut after years in documentary, has called Primetime a “fever dream” rather than a literal recreation, and the film behaves accordingly. Pattinson’s Hansen is part journalist, part prosecutor, part television star and part creature that has begun feeding on its own reflection. A24 Films
He enters rooms slowly.
He pauses.
He lowers his voice.
He lets silence do the work.
Then he asks someone to have a seat.
Pattinson has found the rhythm.
More importantly, he has found the appetite.
His Hansen does not merely want to expose predators. He wants the scene.
He wants the entrance.
He wants the close-up.
He wants the moment when the person across from him realizes that the conversation has already become television.
That distinction is the movie.
And for long stretches, it is a very good one.
Primetime follows Hansen, producer Andie Bender — played with wonderfully exhausted intelligence by Merritt Wever — and young actor Dan Plumb, played by Skyler Gisondo, as the Predator operation becomes bigger, more successful and increasingly difficult to distinguish from the machinery it claims to be exposing.
Gisondo’s Dan is hired to play underage decoys.
Think about that for a moment.
An adult actor pretends to be a child so that another adult will enter a fake house expecting to meet that child, after which hidden cameras record the encounter and a television host appears to transform it into a moral confrontation.
This is journalism.
This is law enforcement.
This is theater.
This is television.
This is America.
Nobody in Primetime seems entirely sure where one category ends and the next begins.
Neither does the movie.
That is both its greatest strength and, eventually, its most convenient escape hatch.
Oppenheim has made the film look genuinely unpleasant.
Not ugly.
Unpleasant.
Cinematographer David Bolen shot portions at an extremely high exposure index to create digital grain, then printed the footage to 16mm to dirty it up further. Vintage broadcast cameras were also used for sections of the film, particularly as Hansen’s perspective becomes more subjective and distorted. Motion Pictures Association
The result looks as though somebody left a VHS tape in a damp basement for twenty years and then screened it inside your skull.
I spent much of Primetime wanting to wipe the movie off my glasses.
I was not wearing glasses.
This is a compliment.
The visual grime matters because Oppenheim understands something important about the era.
Early-2000s television did not look clean.
Reality television, local news, hidden-camera footage, cable crime shows — all of it had a texture.
Bad lighting.
Video noise.
Overexposed faces.
Graphics designed by somebody who had just discovered gradients.
Primetime does not nostalgically recreate that look.
It weaponizes it.
The movie suggests that the ugliness was part of the attraction.
The images felt real because they looked cheap.
And the cheaper they looked, the easier it became to forget that someone was arranging them.

Pattinson understands this too.
He gives one of those performances where you can practically watch an actor discovering how much room the movie will allow him to take up.
Quite a lot, as it turns out.
His Hansen is precise until he isn’t.
Professional until he isn’t.
Moral until morality becomes indistinguishable from performance.
At times he seems less like a journalist than a man directing his own legend in real time.
This is dangerous material for an actor because there is a very thin line between “deliberately artificial” and “Saturday Night Live impression.”
Pattinson walks directly onto that line and begins doing cartwheels.
Somehow, he survives.
Pattinson’s Hansen does not merely want to expose predators. He wants the scene.
Wever may actually have the harder job.
Andie understands what they are doing.
She understands why it works.
She understands why people watch.
And she understands that every moral crusade scheduled between commercial breaks still has to deliver ratings.
Wever plays this without making her a villain, which is important.
The movie is less interesting when it points fingers than when it shows everybody convincing themselves that their particular compromise is the reasonable one.
Gisondo is the closest thing the film has to an innocent.
Which, in Primetime, means he lasts approximately fifteen minutes before the machinery begins changing him too.
There is a nice cruelty in watching Dan learn that being noticed is its own narcotic.
The cameras see him.
The producers praise him.
He gets better at the deception.
Then he starts enjoying being good at it.
This is how show business works.
Usually there is less police tape.
Oppenheim is very good at showing process.
The fake houses.
The props.
The hidden cameras.
The discussions about where somebody should stand.
The small adjustments designed to make a supposedly spontaneous moment play better on television.
You begin to understand why he was drawn to this story.
He comes from documentaries, and Primetime is obsessed with the point where documenting reality quietly becomes arranging it. Oppenheim himself has described the original program as a collision of real impulses with actors, constructed environments and hidden cameras, with Hansen functioning as the ringmaster. A24 Films
That word matters.
Ringmaster.
Because Primetime keeps asking whether the circus remains morally clean simply because the people entering the tent have done something terrible.
This is where the movie becomes complicated.
And where I began arguing with it.
The easiest version of Primetime would say that To Catch a Predator was exploitative trash.
The movie is smarter than that.
The next-easiest version would say Chris Hansen was a noble journalist corrupted by fame.
The movie is smarter than that too.
Instead, it hangs around in the unpleasant middle.
The work matters.
The people being caught are not harmless.
The spectacle is real.
The ethical problems are real.
The ratings are real.
The desire to keep the machine running is very real.
Good.
That is where the movie should be.
But Primetime occasionally mistakes ambiguity for profundity.
There are moments when it raises a difficult question, stares at you intensely, and then seems very pleased that a difficult question has been raised.
Yes.
I see the question.
Would anyone like to answer it?
No?
All right.
Carry on.
The final stretch, which draws on the controversial Texas operation that helped bring To Catch a Predator under intense scrutiny, is the point where the movie's moral haze thickens into something darker.
I will not spoil the particulars.
The film fictionalizes and condenses real events, and Hansen himself has strongly disputed its portrayal and was not involved in the production. People.com
That creates a problem the movie is smart enough to understand but perhaps not brave enough to confront directly.
Can you make a film criticizing television for turning real people into dramatic characters while turning a real television personality into a dramatic character?
Of course you can.
Movies do this every week.
The more interesting question is whether Primetime has earned the distinction it wants to make between its own transformation and the one it condemns.
I am not entirely convinced.
The film would probably argue that it is not offering truth.
It is offering interpretation.
Fine.
So was television.
That is what makes the whole thing interesting.
And irritating.
And worth discussing.
Which may be the point.
Oppenheim's movie is strongest when it stops trying to diagnose Hansen and simply watches the machinery around him.
The producers.
The cops.
The decoys.
The editors.
The cameras.
Everyone has a job.
Everyone has a reason.
Everyone can explain why what they are doing is necessary.
Nobody appears to notice that the show itself has become a character.
Then again, maybe they do.
Maybe that is why they keep feeding it.
There was a time when millions of people watched the same television program at the same time and then went to work the next morning and talked about it.
Primetime treats that era almost like ancient Rome.
A primetime slot mattered.
Ratings mattered.
A face on network television could become nationally recognizable overnight.
Today we have solved this problem by allowing everybody to broadcast everything to everyone at all times.
Much healthier.
The movie could push that connection harder.
It gestures toward the internet ecosystem that followed Hansen — amateur stings, viral humiliation, vigilante content, personality becoming brand becoming meme — but it remains largely trapped in 2006.
That may be historically appropriate.
It also lets the movie stop just before the argument becomes most uncomfortable.
Because the real legacy of To Catch a Predator is not that television became more exploitative.
It is that television's methods escaped television.
Now everybody has a camera.
Everybody has an audience.
Everybody can confront somebody.
Everybody can upload the footage.
We eliminated the network executive.
Efficiency.
Still, I kept thinking about Primetime after it ended.
That matters.
Most bad movies answer questions nobody asked.
Most mediocre movies answer them badly.
Primetime asks good questions, answers some of them, dodges others and occasionally behaves as though the dodge itself deserves applause.
Annoying.
But alive.
Pattinson is terrific.
Wever is terrific.
Gisondo is better than the role initially appears to require.
Oppenheim's direction is aggressive, ugly and confident.
Bolen's photography makes the entire movie look morally contaminated.
And the film understands something unpleasant about media that has only become more obvious with time:
People do not merely watch punishment.
They watch the performance of punishment.
On the Shermometer, Primetime lands somewhere between “essential viewing” and “please stop looking at me like that.”
Three and a half anvils out of five.
I’m still not sure Primetime knows exactly what it thinks about Chris Hansen.
I’m increasingly convinced that may be why I can’t stop thinking about it.









